The 7 Best Italian Restaurants in Philadelphia

Philadelphia is a city rich in culinary diversity, and among its most beloved offerings is the vibrant world of Italian cuisine. Whether you’re in the mood for a cozy trattoria or a chic ristorante, our guide to the 7 Best Italian Restaurants in Philadelphia will help you discover the finest places to indulge in authentic Italian flavors. From traditional pasta dishes to mouth-watering Neapolitan pizzas, these establishments promise a dining experience that captures the essence of Italy.

When choosing an Italian restaurant in Philadelphia, consider the following aspects:

Authenticity: Look for menus featuring classic dishes made with traditional techniques and high-quality ingredients.
Ambiance: The atmosphere can range from rustic and cozy to elegant and contemporary, enhancing your dining experience.
Service: Attentive and knowledgeable staff who can recommend dishes and pairings make a big difference.
Wine Selection: A well-curated list of Italian wines can complement the meal perfectly, offering both popular and rare selections.
Price Range: Prices can vary, so check to ensure the restaurant fits your budget, whether it’s a casual meal or a special occasion.
Location: Consider the neighborhood and its accessibility, especially if you plan to explore the area before or after dining.

Our carefully curated list will guide you to a memorable dining experience, whether you’re a long-time lover of Italian food or exploring it for the first time. Each restaurant has been chosen for its unique contribution to Philadelphia’s rich culinary tapestry, ensuring that your taste of Italy is both authentic and unforgettable.

1. Maggiano's Little Italy
2. The Couch Tomato Café
3. Little Sicily Pizza 2

4. Macaroni's
5. Giorgio on Pine
6. Cafe Michelangelo
7. Osteria

Number of companies

14134

Verified reviews

4,47

Average rating

(215)5672020

1. Maggiano's Little Italy

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

1201 Filbert St, 19107.0, Philadelphia

Italian restaurant
Bar
Caterer
Event venue
Family restaurant
Lunch restaurant
Takeout Restaurant
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Maggiano’s Little Italy has established itself as a beloved destination for those seeking authentic Italian cuisine in a warm, family-friendly environment. With over 30 years of tradition, the restaurant offers a delightful array of Italian-American dishes inspired by classic recipes, ensuring a memorable dining experience for guests. From family-style starters to pasta favorites like Spaghetti and Meatballs and Mom’s Lasagna, each dish is crafted with passion and authenticity. In addition to dining in, patrons can enjoy the convenience of takeout, making it easy to savor these flavors at home.

Located in the vibrant heart of Philadelphia, this restaurant is not only a dining venue but also offers services as a bar, caterer, and event venue. It stands out for its rich menu offerings, which include lunch, dinner, and catering options, ensuring a versatile experience for all occasions. With Executive Chef Scott Halle at the helm since 2022, the culinary team is dedicated to maintaining a culture of excellence and teamwork. Whether celebrating with family or enjoying a quiet meal, guests are invited to experience the exceptional taste and atmosphere that have made this establishment a cherished part of the community.

(215)4832233

2. The Couch Tomato Café

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

102 Rector St, 19127.0, Philadelphia

Italian restaurant
Cafe
Caterer
Restaurant
Pizza restaurant
Salad shop
Sandwich shop

Why we chose them

The Couch Tomato Café, Manayunk stands out for its commitment to fresh, locally sourced American fare, making it a noteworthy addition to our directory. Established in 2003 by Craig Mosmen and Mike Cassano, this vibrant eatery offers a diverse menu featuring customizable artisan pizzas, fresh salads, panini, and homemade soups. With a focus on quality, the café provides a variety of gluten-free, vegetarian, vegan, and kid-friendly options, ensuring there’s something for everyone. The thin-crust New York style pizza, enhanced with top-quality tomato products and sharp farmer’s cheese, highlights their dedication to superior taste and freshness.

The café operates as an Italian restaurant, cafe, caterer, pizza restaurant, salad shop, and sandwich shop, reflecting its versatility and appeal to a broad audience. A proud proponent of a scratch kitchen, the café emphasizes the integrity of its products and the quality of its offerings. Whether dining in or utilizing their catering services, customers can expect an extraordinary culinary experience. The focus on customer satisfaction and superior product quality illustrates why this establishment is a distinguished choice for dining in the Manayunk area.

(215)4658787

3. Little Sicily Pizza 2

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

1608 S Christopher Columbus Blvd, 19148.0, Philadelphia

Italian restaurant
Cheesesteak restaurant
Pizza restaurant

Why we chose them

Little Sicily Pizza 2 stands out for its unique fusion of traditional Italian flavors and innovative Indian-style cheesesteaks. This pizzeria offers a delightful array of options that cater to diverse culinary tastes, making it a must-visit for those seeking something beyond the ordinary. Known for their savory pizza and delectable sandwiches, they bring a creative twist to classic dishes, ensuring a memorable dining experience for all their patrons.

Chosen for our directory due to its distinctive blend of cuisines, this establishment successfully combines the essence of an Italian restaurant and a cheesesteak restaurant. Their commitment to quality and flavor is evident in every bite, attracting food enthusiasts who appreciate both authenticity and innovation. With a reputation for excellent service and a menu that promises to excite the palate, this pizzeria exemplifies culinary excellence in every dish they serve.

(215)4643040

4. Macaroni's

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

9315 Old Bustleton Ave, 19115.0, Philadelphia

Italian restaurant
Bar

Why we chose them

Macaroni’s has established itself as a beloved fixture in Northeast Philadelphia, seamlessly combining old-world charm with a modern culinary experience. Known for its passion for simple Italian comfort foods, the menu draws inspiration from the rich tapestry of Italian culture and cuisine. This dedication to authentic flavors is paired with a commitment to using seasonal and sustainable local ingredients, ensuring every dish is both fresh and flavorful. The restaurant has become a go-to spot for those seeking the best pizza in the area, as well as a variety of other Italian delights, making it a standout choice for lunch or dinner.

Adding to the allure is the P SQUARE Lounge, a hidden gem within the establishment. This versatile indoor-outdoor space offers a unique setting for private parties, birthdays, or simply enjoying a well-deserved happy hour. The lounge’s wood-fired pizza oven and selection of craft brews and house cocktails provide an inviting atmosphere for relaxation and enjoyment. As a neighborhood staple, Macaroni’s not only delivers exceptional Italian cuisine but also offers a warm, inviting environment perfect for any occasion, reaffirming its status as one of the best dining destinations in Northeast Philly.

(215)5456265

5. Giorgio on Pine

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,6/5

1328 Pine St, 19107.0, Philadelphia

Italian restaurant
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Giorgio On Pine is a charming, casual Italian restaurant located in the heart of Center City, Philadelphia. This rustic BYOB trattoria is renowned for its authentic Italian cuisine, crafted with seasonal, fresh, and locally sourced ingredients. The menu showcases classic Roman dishes, ensuring a fine dining experience in a relaxed atmosphere. With a focus on inclusivity, the restaurant offers a separate gluten-free menu, and many dishes can be customized to meet gluten-free preferences. This makes it an ideal spot for anyone seeking genuine Italian flavors in a welcoming setting.

Known for its vibrant dining experience, the restaurant has recently expanded to include a second location right next door. This expansion reflects its popularity and commitment to serving more patrons while maintaining the high quality of its offerings. The establishment not only provides a delightful dining experience but also caters to various needs with options for online ordering, catering, and hosting private parties. The dedication to seasonal specials ensures that every visit offers something new and exciting, making it a standout choice for Italian cuisine enthusiasts.

(215)6982233

6. Cafe Michelangelo

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,2/5

11901 Bustleton Ave, 19116.0, Philadelphia

Italian restaurant

Why we chose them

Cafe Michelangelo is a beloved Italian restaurant nestled in Somerton, Philadelphia, known for its traditional pizza and pasta offerings. This family-owned establishment has been delighting diners with its authentic wood-fired pizzas and handmade pasta, ensuring a dining experience packed with flavor. Beyond its celebrated Italian cuisine, the cafe boasts a fantastic menu featuring massive, juicy burgers, great sandwiches, and gluten-free dishes, catering to a diverse palate. With a warm, friendly atmosphere and an extensive wine selection, it’s an ideal spot for romantic dates or family gatherings.

The restaurant excels in hosting special events, offering catering services for everything from corporate functions to holiday parties. Known for its vibrant live music and craft cocktail menu, the venue provides a lively backdrop for celebrations such as weddings, bar mitzvahs, and bridal showers. With a focus on quality and fresh ingredients, it ensures every event is bespoke to the customer’s tastes and needs. Whether you’re planning an office function or a family reunion, the attentive staff at Cafe Michelangelo will handle all the details, making every occasion memorable.

(215)7630920

7. Osteria

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

640 N Broad St, 19130.0, Philadelphia

Italian restaurant
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Osteria, a renowned Italian restaurant, offers a rustic dining experience that has captivated food enthusiasts since its opening in 2007. Known for its authentic Italian cuisine, Osteria focuses on traditional Northern Italian techniques, utilizing a wood-burning grill and custom-made brick oven to craft seasonal menus. The restaurant features an ever-changing selection of fresh, hand-made pastas, perfectly paired with a diverse array of wines. The lush ambiance enhances the dining experience, providing a charming backdrop for enjoying Osteria’s acclaimed dishes. Notably, the culinary excellence at Osteria earned Chef Jeff Michaud the prestigious 2010 James Beard Foundation Award for “Best Chef: Mid-Atlantic.”

Beyond its dining offerings, Osteria provides a range of services that cater to special occasions and private events. With options for weddings, rehearsals, and private dining, the restaurant ensures that every celebration is memorable. Osteria’s interactive cooking classes, led by Chef Michaud, offer a unique hands-on experience, allowing participants to learn the art of making pizza or pasta. This blend of exquisite food, award-winning service, and engaging culinary experiences makes Osteria a standout choice for those seeking authentic Italian flavors in a warm, inviting setting.

FAQs

What services can I expect at an Italian restaurant in Philadelphia?

Italian restaurants in Philadelphia typically offer a range of services including dine-in, takeout, and delivery. They often provide a diverse menu featuring pasta, pizza, seafood, and desserts, along with a selection of Italian wines.

How much does it cost to dine at an Italian restaurant in Philadelphia?

The average cost for a meal at an Italian restaurant in Philadelphia ranges from €20 to €50 per person, depending on the restaurant's ambiance and menu offerings.

What should I consider when choosing an Italian restaurant in Philadelphia?

Consider the authenticity of the menu, the ambiance of the restaurant, the quality of service, the wine selection, price range, and the location's convenience.

How do I know if an Italian restaurant offers authentic cuisine?

Look for menus that feature traditional Italian dishes made with high-quality, authentic ingredients and traditional cooking techniques. Reviews and recommendations can also be a good indicator of authenticity.

What is the typical timeline for dining at an Italian restaurant?

Dining at an Italian restaurant usually takes about 1 to 2 hours, depending on the number of courses ordered and the restaurant's service pace.

Are reservations required at Italian restaurants in Philadelphia?

While not always required, making a reservation is recommended, especially during weekends or at popular dining times, to ensure you secure a table.

What type of wine selection should I expect at an Italian restaurant?

Italian restaurants often offer a curated selection of Italian wines, including both popular and rare varieties, to complement their dishes. You can expect reds, whites, and sparkling wines from various regions of Italy.

What are some tips for enjoying a meal at an Italian restaurant?

Take your time to savor each course, ask the staff for wine pairings, and don't hesitate to try new dishes. Engaging with the staff for recommendations can enhance your dining experience.